Matthew Hirschy

Matthew G. Hirschy is Senior Vice President & Treasurer at Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company, a Fort Wayne-based insurer focused on churches and related Christian ministries. Brotherhood Mutual’s leadership page lists him among senior executive staff with CPA and CPCU credentials, and the company’s directors page lists him as a director of both Brotherhood Mutual Holding Company and Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company.

Hirschy joined Brotherhood Mutual in 2008 as vice president of finance and chief financial officer, became treasurer in 2009, and assumed his current senior vice president role in July 2018, according to The Org’s profile. A March 16, 2009 Insurance Journal item also reported that he had joined Brotherhood Mutual in August 2008 and was elected treasurer and added to the board.

Before Brotherhood Mutual, Hirschy spent four years as chief financial officer at a Fort Wayne biomedical firm and 15 years as a certified public accountant, including 12 years at a local accounting firm and three years at Ernst & Young LLP. He holds an accounting degree from Manchester University, earned his CPA license in 1989, and received his CPCU designation in 2016.

Hirschy is also listed in IRS-derived filings as treasurer of Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc., a 501(c)(3) private grantmaking foundation in Fort Wayne. ProPublica’s Nonprofit Explorer shows him as treasurer in recent filings, including the fiscal-year 2024 filing, where the foundation reported $3.8 million in charitable disbursements.

• No public source found verifies Hirschy as an active angel investor, seed investor, venture capitalist, or manager of a personal investment fund.
• The investable/strategic pattern visible in public sources is corporate and mission-focused rather than VC-style: Brotherhood Mutual says its mission is “Advancing the Kingdom by serving the Church,” and its stated focus is ministry-focused insurance products, risk management services, and adjacent services.
• Public sources connect Hirschy to Brotherhood Mutual’s partnership activity in the ministry-services market. Remodel Health CEO Austin Lehman described a partnership with Brotherhood Mutual and named Mark Robison, Matt Hirschy, and Michael Allison as people involved; Remodel Health’s own company history says it formed an official partnership with Brotherhood Mutual in 2018.
• There is no verified public check size, seed-stage mandate, or personal angel thesis for Hirschy.